Tuesday, June 2, 2015

IT'S NOT FAIR!!



This week been thinking about FAIR because two women much beloved by BJM had incredible, unexpected good news.  They both got HOUSING!

S. was eligible as part of an Obama administration effort to house homeless vets and former foster children under age 24.  A case worker helped her apply. She’s a former runaway with a severe, congenital disability. She’s been on the streets for the past 2+ years while (drum roll here) attending City College of San Francisco!

On Wednesday, S. moved into a small apartment right across the street from her SCHOOL! (I’m about to go all-out and just type a whole line of exclamation points). Amazing. Impossible!  Plus, she won’t be in the Tenderloin anymore!!!!!

Whew…that was exhausting.

Then, my beloved kid “K” told me she was going to get “a place.”  Frankly, I thought it was wishful thinking or confusion or even a scam.  K has been offered housing before with a not-uncommon “catch” of sex as payment.  So, I wanted to see the place. Meet the director. Check the whole thing out.

Whoa! It was legit. And, she had suddenly – for no reason – moved to the top of the waiting list.

The studio apartment, in the Tenderloin, is located in an old but well-kept hotel. Beautiful murals in the entry were probably WPA artist-grant projects in the 1930s. The apartment is small but clean. Wood floors, a private bath and tiny kitchen area. 

The most amazing part of this is that K received this apartment without the usual 2+ year wait or the sometimes=even-longer Lottery system!  She applied and was told “YES”….We spent last Friday discovering just how much stuff I can tie to the roof rack of my car.  Picking up furniture, kitchenware, a bookshelf listed “free” on Craigslist.  I went to Goodwill and bought a comfy chair, small shelving unit and a stool so she can sit at the counter and eat.  2 plates, 2 bowls, 2 sets of silverware and mugs….  A lovely San Franciscan moving to Sweden for a new job gifted K with bedding and pillows. 

I felt such joy. And such inner conflict.

Because another friend, C, has been waiting for more than 2 years for housing.  C has done it all “by the book”….Filling out forms, Re-filling out forms when they were lost or expired or who-knows-what bureaucratic stupidity.  Walking from office to office.  Walking with a walker because C. was injured in a serious fall years ago…the injury was so severe that she couldn’t work….lost her job….and with it, her health insurance…..because ObamaCare didn’t exist then, her medical bills thrust her into bankruptcy…Lost her home and ended up on the streets (this is an all-too-common story here in the Tenderloin)

Today, C. needs hip replacement surgery related to that injury that led to homelessness…and now, CAN’T have the surgery until she has a place to live.  (WHAT?  Yep…she can’t have surgery and be released to the streets….and is still on the streets unable to work because she needs the surgery)

So, C does everything the system asks. Dots her I’s and everything else in sight….and K gets an apartment in a few weeks. 

I am so grateful that K is no longer on the streets. SO hopeful that having stable housing will be the key that opens the door to healing of trauma, recovery of identity, and a new vision for life that includes good things like work and stable relationships.  This is so GOOD.

AND, another part of my mind is screaming; “IT’S NOT FAIR!” C should have a place to live!  C should have gotten housing first.

I talked to Father about it. Here are some thoughts from that conversation:
            *the world lives with a mindset of scarcity and Law
            * The world acts based on the belief that there isn’t enough, and we need to work hard because we get what we deserve
            * God doesn’t give us what we deserve. It’s called Grace…
·      Grace isn’t fair
o   God isn’t fair…and it’s not just about getting into heaven “free of charge” without having to earn any status as His Children
o   God loves K and loves C.  And, what happened isn’t fair.
o   But God IS good.

God is good. I don’t believe for one moment that we should nod sagely and mumble, “It’s God’s will that Carmen is homeless…He will be glorified through it…just wait…”
I reject the lie that God “wills” pain and evil to happen so that He can accomplish some bigger plan.  Or, that He arbitrarily dispenses good things to some and leaves others in the lurch…

I feel so happy and so sad. I can’t fix the system that left C homeless, broke, and sick after a lifetime of hard work and responsibility.  I can’t fix the system that ignored K – a 10 year-old runaway from a sexually abusive home…and failed to protect her at almost every level.
It isn’t helpful for me to ask “why” K got housing and C  - whose immediate need is more critical – is still homeless.  I suppose any answer to “why” is too massive…touching on greed, sin, economic power, corruption and human failure to care.

I’m left with the freeing, hopeful good news that God isn’t fair. We don’t need to fear because He isn’t keeping score.  But God is good. Absolutely good.  And that Truth  is hope.